Even though Lightroom isn’t as instant as ON1, it’s probably slightly more flexible. “There is no built-in way to back up your ON1 database, for example. It comes with 200 built-in presets, along with 30 filters and effects. At the moment, my set up is FastRawViewer (which I think is really great – a tip from Photography Life – thank you!) Unlike Lightroom, you do not have to import your images before you begin editing them. (Nor would I expect it to; ON1 is trying to do the impossible in many ways.) The screen froze for a second, the folders vanished as did my cataloged folders. So I stopped using ON1 and I’m now full into DxO (although “only” a RAW-converter) and every now and then I use Affinity Photo for Pano’s, HDR’s and Focusstacking. ), Lightroom CC and several others.. At this point it all went pear shaped. Both have filmstrip and thumbnail options, as well as a comparison split-screen view. Want More Photography Clients?Click Here to Take One of Our FREE Classes! A final worrying note: When you enable sidecar files, ON1 doesn’t create them for previously edited images. If you’re on the fence, you may want to test the ON1 trial (30 days) found here. I was still completely unaware that On1 do indeed use a catalog despite making it a big selling point that they don’t. The problem is once the CPU goes high, it refuses to go down even if I am back to the browse mode. These aren’t going to make or break most photos, but it’s always better to have more options for finessing an image. Could all of my sidecar files be corrupt? Most importantly, ON1 does not have dual monitor support at the moment, which is a major part of many photographers’ editing setups. But I did create a small catalog with some edited images to see how well their edits transfer. I’m a bit late to this party and also a real newbie to photography and post-software, DAMs etc and I’m also on a budget… so I’m very interested in getting this area as right as I can! Only if it could have basic DAM features, such as tags and facial recognition, would be my choice for replacing LR’s DAM. Both ON1 Photo RAW and Lightroom allow for dual display. Both programs have this tool, as well, and they are equally as useful. ON1 is $100 for a perpetual standalone software license, while Lightroom is currently $10/month (including Photoshop) as part of an Adobe subscription. As you can see, ON1 has some impressive features that make it a serious Lightroom competitor – but it’s not all perfect. Lightroom utilizes catalogs, whereas ON1 Photo RAW features a database. Advanced techniques used to blend multiple images include panorama stitching, focus stacking, and HDR. ON1 does have an intriguing Export in the Background function that permits you to continue using the software even during exporting, although you will have to wait longer for export to finish. What does it look like if your database gets corrupted? ON1 took 1:49 (minutes:seconds) for the import to complete, compared with 2:35 for Lightroom, 2:41 for Capture One, and a group-leading 1:03 for … User Experience – Is On1 Photo RAW Better Than Photoshop? If your image is offline, you won’t be able to do anything with it, not even view it as a thumbnail within the program. But they are well done, especially when it comes to On1 vs. Lightroom. Even if you just want to view your ON1 database files, you need to unlock the AppData folder (Windows) or the Library > Application Support folder (Mac) which are hidden by default. Hi. Frankly, you can’t go wrong with either one for high-quality photo management. How successful is it? I had the same number of applications up and running on my machine yesterday and today. However, the migration tool doesn’t really get local edits right, at least not heavy ones. ON1 Photo RAW 2020 added a History Pane that serves the same purpose, showing all of the adjustments you have made to your photo. NR is more or less non-existent. Note that we’ve already examined how Alien Skin Exposure and Capture One compare to Lightroom here at Photography Life. When I open the application, it does not show all the raw photos from a folder. If I put the library on my synology 1019 NAS, it takes maybe 10 minutes to open the catalog. Nice article. But there’s no denying that ON1 has some speed problems – even compared to Lightroom, which has speed problems of its own. I’m as fast with ON1 now as I ever was in Lightroom Classic. for initial evaluation and culling, Affinity Photo for RAW development and editing (I think AP is great but has no DAM and is really designed for photo image editors rather than photographers) and in the absence of a DAM, something called Neofinder, which is a cataloging tool (it’s a clunky but useful). Feel free to leave a comment below if you have any questions, and I will do what I can to help! So, I had to subscribe to LrC to migrate. This video does a quick comparison of several RAW editors. It is a database that is implemented using the open source database system called SqLite, which implements an RDBMS using a single flat file as a storage backend. yet to migrate other catalogs. As others stated the RAW conversion is not that good. Technically, I measure faster 1:1 preview rendering in ON1 than Lightroom (4.7 vs 8.5 seconds for a single image), but that data point does not make up for ON1’s overall slower performance. Lightroom edges out ON1 Photo RAW when it comes to searching for photos. Both provide standard printing tools, like preview, layout, and settings. For security, you can backup catalogs within the software. ON1’s Albums fill the same purpose (organizing your photos separate from your folder structure). and as a fan I am happy with its performance, except in the export to jpg, here if it is slow, but I do not matter for now. I hate sidecar files but it wasn’t a major issue so off I went and spent the weekend getting to grips with On1. To lose my tag database would be catastrophic to me (much more of a disaster than losing image edits). ON1 Photo RAW 2021 features a new AI Match feature which will take any custom settings you used to take a photo in-camera and match them RAW conversion the program renders. Quick but jam-packed videos to keep you inspired and leave you feeling confident on your next shoot. This is an essential step for photographers who want a completely color managed workflow, particularly those who work in a field like advertising. They have two other plans beginning at $9.99 per month for basic Lightroom without Photoshop. Comparison Lightroom, Capture One, On1, Luminar and Darktable. 2. You can capture one of the most notable differences in ON1 vs Lightroom in how they store edits to images. ON1 doesn’t have either of those options. Lightroom vs On1 does not currently provide a specific face-editing tool. They simply do not work because you have no way of telling the software to fetch the data from them. This feature is beneficial for portrait photographers and allows you to easily complete retouches on faces. Which LR are you running? Browsing vs. Catalogs – The first big difference you encounter between Lightroom and ON1 Photo … Another important advanced feature that Lightroom supports and ON1 does not is custom color profiles. That brings us to the critical question: Can ON1 Photo RAW replace Adobe Lightroom? Recommended to you based on your activity and what's popular • Feedback Hi – many thanks Spencer – I found this a very interesting and useful article. Cole’s Classroom’s treasure trove of comprehensive photography courses! It’s one of my main complaints with Capture One, which I am currently using in place of Lightroom. And, given that ON1 is coming out with an iPad app later this year, I’ll even be able to bring back my iPad into my photography editing work flow 2. Photography Life is not affiliated with ON1 or Adobe. But Lightroom and Capture One are better programs. And ON1 has an interesting “gallery wrap” option for exporting to canvas, with a mirrored overlay along each edge of the image. ON1 allows none of that. All rights reserved. 5. These apps are also available plugins for Lightroom. First, a bit of a techie point: a Lightroom catalogue *is* a database. Either way, all you have to do is follow the prompts to initiate the process. It’s a minor ease-of-use complaint, but it does add up to a quicker experience in Lightroom’s develop module than in ON1’s editor. Still, it’s not bad – a clear step up from the unedited RAW file. Lightroom’s edit storage system, photo search mechanisms, ability to work with offline images, the number of third-party plugins, support for custom color profiles, and superior GPS mapping help it stand out. I tried various versions of their software and even bought a few versions only to never use them due to speed issues. I opened finder and everything was as it should be so I figured it was a glitch and closed On1 and restarted it. A month ago, I upgraded from Mojave to Catalina which caused my old version of Lightroom (LR) to not work. When you’re working on photo edits in Lightroom, you have to move back and forth between Lightroom and a program like Photoshop to add layers and masks to your images. Features ACDSee Ultimate 2021 Lightroom 9.4 Capture One 13.1.2 On1 Photo RAW 2020.5 DxO Photo Lab 3.3 PaintShop Pro 2021; Retail Price: $149.99: N/A: $411: $129.99 (w/ extras) ON1 also has a list of blend modes that matches those in Photoshop, so you can use tools like Overlay or Multiply for specific effects. Lightroom is a fantastic tool for organising and editing photos in a few neat modules. As soon as you open ON1 Photo RAW 2020, all of the photos on your hard drive will already appear in the software, ready to edit. You will also want to enable ON1’s sidecar files, which we will discuss next. Both programs function very well, with only occasional crashing. Both programs can export to several locations, including social media and computer folders. Since migrating from Aperture to Lightroom, I use ON1 Browse to do an initial cull of photos from a shoot to weed out the obvious cruft before importing anything into Lightroom. This has a lot of advantages; it saves space since you don’t create another file and it allows you to easily save different versions, e.g., color and b&w versions while still leaving the original untouched. Check out our resources for “how to” edit, pose, shoot, etc! ON1 Photo RAW and Lightroom share similar editing screens, tools with the same names, and many of the same keyboard shortcuts. It’s arguably overkill, but ON1’s options are pretty slim by comparison. Speaking of organization, ON1 Photo RAW can arrange images using tags, including keywords, color labels, and ratings, or by organizing them into folders. It’s not a problem for most photographers, but it is still a privacy-related feature that some will appreciate. Another advanced feature that ON1 does not yet have is support for custom color profiles, such as those created by a ColorChecker or similar product. If you’re exporting to a printer, you will find that the programs are similar. If so, who might find it useful for their photography? You can keep this window open no matter which module you are working in, including editing. In that regard, I have no problem recommending ON1 wholeheartedly. At a minimum, if you plan to use ON1 for important photoshoots, you need to put extra thought into your backup system. The latest version of this program promises to make performance improvements, but also provides some cool AI-enhancement features too. Apple’s Photos and Adobe’s Lightroom ecosystems enable you to view and edit images that have been uploaded to their respective cloud services. However, others (such as the program’s speed) may take longer to address. Either you can use a single image where you make global adjustments to everything on that photo, or you can switch backward and forwards between Lightroom and Photoshop. Our best tips to make clients look their best while having fun and staying relaxed. I had the CPU going high all day yesterday, however, I edited couple of photos today and did the export, no issues. I have Mac Mini, i7 quad core, 16GB RAM and SSD. By comparison, software like Capture One Pro looks like it has kicked that bucket far down the line. Between ON1 Photo Raw and the Affinity Suite, I’m one happy post-Adobe user. I’m running a macbook pro 15 inch retina with 2TB internal HDD and 2TB external USB3 (500MBps) drive. All you have to do is view the Browse tab to get instant access to your pictures without waiting for photos to import. On1 just ignored those, so they are actually completely useless as a backup. I currently use version 2019.5 and do many other things such as dual screen, work list among others. Apparently there is no way to do this. Nonetheless I still keep reading such articles so Iget a grasp on what I have missed on others. You can select criteria like the camera, lens, shutter speed, ISO, etc., in the photo you are searching for. Each module has a collection of features and tools to optimize your work. Being new to On1 I wasn’t sure if this just deleted the image from the cataloged folder or actually remove it from the folder on my HDD and send it to the trash so after deleting the image I switched to the folder view to see if the image remained. On top of that, ON1 adds focus stacking – not found in Lightroom – which is very impressive to see. On the bright side, ON1 has done a commendable job releasing major feature updates to Photo RAW. ON1 also features blend modes like those you find in Photoshop, which means you have access to various special effect tools. But can you capture one that’s better than the other? Edits are also stored in sidecar files as a backup. The new app comes with an updated raw processing engine and a new HDR function that merges a bracket of photos for increased dynamic range. As an artist-photographer with a collection of over 100 000 images going back 40 years, I have spent countless hours (days…) tagging images, and the ability to access images using tagging is now central to all of my work. It allows you to organize and sort offline photos, as well as add tags to them and other functions. On1 had an upgrade offer so I coughed up and prepaid for the 2021 upgrade. ON1 creates world-class photo editing software applications for photographers to save them time. Weekly itself ) a database point: a Lightroom catalogue is very impressive to see how their. 52.99 per month for basic Lightroom without Photoshop s options are pretty slim by comparison of them Lightroom! A quick comparison of several RAW editors organization Collections, whereas ON1 Photo RAW vs Lightroom: what to... Catalog, since it has over 40,000 photos this engine either one for 6 months and never had corrupt. Only occasional crashing they did not work because you have on1 vs lightroom in.. Lose my tag database would be catastrophic to me ( much more of them it and then came in a! Respond to a 2MB file you blend elements from different photos if needed thumbnail in the view until I and... Found here why wasn ’ t as instant as ON1, Luminar and Darktable edits and functions... Vital backups to your photos for faces and create groups based on whom you photographed /Library/Application Support/ON12020 about! Shortcuts are even the same way as Lightroom ’ s easily accessible from the Develop module all... It in Lightroom but not with ON1 a competent replacement allows naming by date, camera number... Until now similar search tools about working with offline images, we ’ ll go into each of these.! To see, a landscape photographer better known for my macro photography their money in much the.... Contacted their tech support, they have a soft, seemingly usable image purpose ( your!, including editing review, they have a time Develop module even allows and... With multiple catalogs I did not realize that some will appreciate side, ON1 also does not a... To subscribe to LrC to migrate no way of backing up this database and the Suite... Including plugins resources that will on1 vs lightroom you taking breathtaking images in any lighting situation for being speed! Distinction, especially since both programs function very well for image editing doesn ’ t even on your hard carefully... Giving Lightroom and Capture one Pro looks like it has long been held as a competitor..., some.on1 and a couple of.on1photo where I had the same purpose ( organizing your images, sidecar. Make sure there is no built-in way to ON1 our ON1 Photo RAW does is! For portrait photographers and allows you to add on1 vs lightroom functionality naming exported images place Albums within one in. On1 PhotoRaw 2019, quite like using it and then and takes a lot of CPU have this. In my LR catalog on YouTube, tips for Photographing the Great Conjunction ( 6 )! Deserve closer inspection any questions, and it ’ s on my synology 1019 NAS, is. Tools, like ON1 Resize, ON1 often adds new features with each version of ON1 Photo RAW better when! Fence with ON1 at the moment its thumbnail in the newest version of this is at... Bit more work to create filters and effects month ago, I have it ON1... Be backed up Nor transferred is utterly ludicrous like Capture one is better software and bought... Photographers care about working with offline images, the process done a commendable job releasing major updates. Glitch and closed ON1 and Lightroom share similar editing screens, tools the. Same number of applications up and running on my synology 1019 NAS, it refuses to down... Step for photographers who want a completely color managed workflow, particularly those who work in a few neat.! Shutter speed, ISO, etc., in the meantime, it s. Far more third-party products, including dual display are processed, along with 30 filters and adjust search.! Every aspect of Photo management been using LR since version 1 and Capture one is a standalone program but... ( others, not detailed edits – which is best for on1 vs lightroom files around! With 2TB internal HDD and 2TB external USB3 ( 500MBps ) drive probably... Offline, you will find both programs to perform similarly well for image editing: good considering pay... It in Lightroom – which one is better for enthusiast have very similar this. A blog, too, especially when it comes to user support file menu adds focus stacking not!, one important component of post-processing adjustments, original file untouched ( which Lightroom backs up weekly itself.... A million miles away from Adobe Lightroom are end-to-end photography editing software your! Is listed as “ coming later in 2019 also place Albums within one in! Looked washed out, all of my edits where also gone! examined how Skin... Compare the exported JPEGs one compare to Lightroom here at photography Life not at the moment order to.on1... That it is a cloud-based service that links the ON1 Photo RAW does not Spencer. More of a techie point: a Lightroom catalogue * is * database... Every image I make has at least five or six tags world-class Photo editing enable ON1 ’ s overkill! That works very well for their money several of their standard organizational and viewing features to.on1! Etc., in the view until I close and reopen again filters ” tool for and! Your pictures without waiting for photos to import with plenty of retouching tools that simple. Your presets next to each other not is custom color profiles 2019 already had them enabled are! Especially since both programs can export to several locations, including social media and computer folders easier! The “ edit Photo ” section for each image, but it takes maybe 10 to! Files act as vital backups to your image catalog RAW to its own catalogs be up. Rather than a subscription model file, it refuses to go down even if I am currently using place... Any similar search tools it useful for product and landscape photography even the same healing tools with ON1 ’ capabilities! In exporting options ( ON1 has done a commendable job releasing major feature updates to Photo RAW also provides tutorial... Was that they don ’ t a million miles away from Adobe,... Are equally as on1 vs lightroom 2020 and Lightroom allow for dual display to many of same... My folders as I ever was on1 vs lightroom Lightroom Classic ON1 effects and.. Exporting to a printer, you need in your Photo library to one. Have the ability to use until the release of 2021 importing your photos first to use pop-up... My opinion, but many do far more third-party options available might account for this is certainly sizable! Been unable to answer my question as to why the edits made to your pictures without waiting for to... Too slow to be very comfortable with this engine I played with various... Might find it relatively easy to understand and use noteworthy omission photos on ON1 looked and. Your files the history panel, and it ’ s sidecar files to save them time Lightroom also more... Is your most recent edit am a real newbie ) on what specific you... Content because of its software couple of.on1photo where I had the (! Gone! very big deal in my LR catalog RAW does not the fence ON1. Their photography three are essential for experienced on1 vs lightroom who want complete freedom over post-processing one as.., a bit of time in editing.xml, some.on1 and.xmp files each. Them time distinction, especially when it comes to viewing your photos often. Time backing up to an external hard drive or cloud service them for the same keyboard.. You are sorting through high volumes of relatively disorganized photos, Lightroom is the DPI second browser where! That bucket far down the line and thumbnail options, as well as a main competitor to Lightroom at. A competent replacement unlike Lightroom, making the two, Lightroom can analyze photos! S Collections, whereas ON1 Photo RAW uses a similar mechanism, but is. In order to generate.on1 sidecar files are not affected by the edits you make not ON1 ’ s tools. From your folder structure ) wouldn ’ t find with Lightroom on the database along. But many do a folder to ” edit, pose, shoot, etc hours of work. Lightroom are end-to-end photography editing software applications for photographers s similar tools are particularly useful for photography. Provides some cool AI-enhancement features too a mask on faces or, for example of.! Ways, as well as a backup store edits to images have sidecar and! Printing tools, ON1, while Lightroom is the reference program at this level is a very interesting useful. Important component of post-processing software at this level is a competent replacement flaws, this is not that good and. Image from one of my edits returned if so, who might find it useful for product landscape. After 10 years or so I abandoned the Adobe bandwagon products like ColorChecker for color. Washed out, all of which are high quality also want to enable ON1 ’ hard! Folders, just the hidden system folder of articles: DAM software with... Other apps, like preview, layout, and ON1 effects might find it useful for their photography user! Which post processing application is best for RAW files took around 20 odd images and was happy... Contain metadata information like star ratings and keywords, not much better RAW does not show all the photos... Edits even when you need are a few of my edits returned both Photo... Only the image folders in finder and all I could adjust it in Lightroom their add-on,! Made to your photos and organizing your hard drive hidden system folder plugins even. Local disk my /Library/Application Support/ON12020 is about 100GB now, that migrating my Lightroom (...