If anything, Luke in a lightsaber battle is the most one-sided fight there is. The original trilogy told the story of Luke Skywalker’s quest to defeat Darth Vader, only to discover along the way that Vader is his corrupted father, Anakin. But if it's the highest point he ever attained, then it's sometime during the end of the Clone Wars. everyone know this. Is there an accurate way to judge what Anakins full potential would be? He essentially slaughters Sith Knights and Lords in the Legacy series. Some may argue that Yoda and Luke deserve to be higher than Kanan and Ezra, but Kanan and Ezra have an extremely unique… He's also got him on lightsaber training as well. If he kills his father then he would take his place as an apprentice; which actually there is something that in the next film is how Anakin becomes his apprentice. Luke is basically the Force's second attempt at making the ultimate force wielder and this time it succeeded. 33. So they should be equal this all comes down to training. Luke is much smarter than Anakin ever was when it came to fights, to be honest. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. He is much more powerful. Yes EU Luke has tons of feats under his belt as well as teachers but there's really no way to say what Anakin was capable of learning or mastering. I know, EU Luke is amazing. Which means Order 66 has been enacted, so there's no Jedi to learn from other than Yoda, who is heading to Dagobah. Rey vs Anakin: 5 Reasons Why Anakin Would Beat Rey (& 5 Reasons Why Rey Will Always Win) ... she was a perfect combination of our favorite Jedi Luke, Anakin, and Obi-Wan Kenobi. Otherwise, Luke doesn't have much of a chance. It seems like we're assuming that when he lost to Obi-wan, that he stopped learning. But let's just imagine Anakin never lost to Obi Wan and dropped his emotional baggage long enough to reach his full potential. If we're saying that "full potential Anakin" is the best warrior he could possibly be, then this wouldn't be an issue. Press J to jump to the feed. As one of the foremost Star Wars Experts on this subreddit, /u/hopeburnsbright's post has my full seal of approval. That being said, EU Luke has way too many teachers and learns the light side of the force, the dark side of the force, the grey side of the force, that oddly magenta side of the force, etc. Don't underestimate the other guys' power, though. There are a lot of things repeated in these movies. Anakin at full potential was equal to the Father of Mortis as he was asked to take his place. … I'm just not sure this is a fair fight it's mostly speculation. Anakin probably grew astronomically more from AotC to RotS than he had in the three year period prior. During the Clone Wars, the Son lured Anakin Skywalker into the Well of the Dark Side and corrupted him with a premonition of the duel on Mustafar. I mean, I think a Skywalker wins 10/10 times. You are indeed where you belong. Darth Vader is going to be better with a lightsaber, I think. This is another debate that has raged on for … But against Anakin, he was simply outmatched. Come join our discussions, post your own battles and kick some ass! Archived. Including just pinning a Sith Lord to a chair while having a casual conversation. He has no use for an apprentice. Luke is much more powerful than Yoda. Everything Luke's learned in that realm is pretty much secondhand, Yoda didn't give him much in terms of actual combat technique, but Anakin trained when Jedi teaching in that realm was at its peak. Cal is about as strong as ESB Luke (Luke more natural potential, Cal more training), and ESB Luke would stand no chance against a young Anakin, so yeah, it's definitely Anakin. young anakin could not slow down time or do half the s*** you can do in … If so, then that would probably mean Luke would most likely be killed along with Uncle Owen and Aunt Beru and basically never becoming EU Luke in the first place, right? He's the emperor. In terms of raw strength he would easily beat Luke. If this was a lightsaber duel, I'd give it to Vader, but if we're really embracing the liberal use of the Force seen in the EU, it's got to go to Luke. So what we have is Darth Vader with full mobility, Anakin's full range of lightsaber fighting goodness, learning actively from Darth Sidious with a lot less resentment. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. That their potential in the Force was equal and everything? Luke was a very good agile defensive fighter, who could pick up and master fighting styles just by watching them in action. Anakin would fucking annihilate Luke, no contest, More posts from the whowouldwin community. This guy is going to be absurdly powerful, Sidious alone was a huge threat to Luke just with clones and other shenaniganry. The first two trilogies in the mainline Star Wars saga — the ones that came from the mind of series creator George Lucas — each revolved around a key figure in the Skywalker bloodline. You are indeed where you belong. Luke in the Expanded Universe apparently had the exact same potential as Anakin did and was insanely powerful. Full potential Anakin is literally Force Jesus. Assuming it's like George said and they have the same potential they would be relatively evenly matched and in that case Luke's tempered aggression and Jedi tranquility combined with his mastery of the darkside means Anakin doesn't have a hope in hell We don't know for sure that Anakin has more force-potential than Luke, Chosen One and 20000 midi-chlorians never really get pulled up since Luke hasn't had a blood test run to compare. Luke being the son of the Chosen One, would not have the potential Anakin would have. Why didn't he win? Luke was good at attacking, but everything he could have done would be blocked and counterattacked! There's no reason that he couldn't have learned the same force related powers that Luke learned and then some. Luke has immense finesse, experience, and wisdom when it comes to how to use it to best serve him. And for that matter, having more potential does not automatically mean you win. On a surface level, these two lines work perfectly, as Anakin (the father) and Luke (the son) are in the exact opposite situations. However, I do believe case could be made that Luke may win if he utilized his Force abilities appropriately he may be able to have the perfect time to strike such as … --George Lucas, ROTJ DVD Commentary. The battle is on the Death Star 2 in the emperors thrones room. Yeah pretty much this. Anakin had way more potential than Dooku, but he got his arm chopped off by Dooku. Now a much more interesting fight is Mara Jade trying to assassinate no suit Darth Vader... Luke's feats with a blade are absurd. Anakin had the potential to be twice as more powerful then Palpatine and so did Luke but due to Anakin’s injuries from Kenobi it is not possible to become twice but possibly equal but Luke only with one cybernetic hand he would be more powerful. All of his force abilities are brute strength lightning/choke/crush. Full potential Anakin, I'm more than positive, would wreck EU Luke. The turning point is that Anakin has 0 patience. Full potential Anakin is literally Force Jesus. Vader let Luke win. Anakin Skywalker (Full Potential) vs Luke Skywalker (Full Potential) Saw a lot of Anakin Skywalker talk so time to go back to the Star Wars universe. Power growth isn't just a matter of Force potential, especially early in training; Luke could've gotten more accelerated teachings, Anakin's growth may have been deliberately restricted, Luke could have been better focused, a faster learner, etc. Including just pinning a Sith Lord to a chair while having a casual conversation. Instead, most of Luke's interactions with Anakin occurred while the latter was still Darth Vader, and the franchise has clearly stated multiple times that Vader and Anakin were essentially two different people. Lucas said, so enough said. he was the equal of Yoda power wise by the end of the NJO series. He fought down the Vong Jedi Hunters with ease and is often described as a tempest in battle. Does this mean Anakin kills Obi Wan? Anakin only in Legends and at full potential is Multi Universal [Stronger then the spirits who created and hold the whole Star Wars Multiverse], And Luke was something like Galaxy Buster to Universal (Fought Abeloth and was able to consistently harm her with his Force Blasts. Okay, since you said never lost to Obi Wan, I'm going to use their fight as the point of divergence from that story line. Depends on who has the high the high ground. Luke reaches a much more enlightened mindset in his prime and has a solid chance of utilizing his patience to overcome Anakin in this scenario. The duel began after Darth Sidious, as the newly appointed Galactic Emperor Sheev Palpatine, tasked Darth Vader, his new apprentice, with the assassination of the leaders of the Confederacy of Independent Systems on the volcanic Outer Rim planet Mustafar, … We don't know for sure that Anakin has more force-potential than Luke, Chosen One and 20000 midi-chlorians never really get pulled up since Luke hasn't had a blood test run to compare. In Episode III, Obi Wan said he didn’t want to fight Anakin because he didn’t dare to kill his own apprentice, but Yoda told him to do so because Darth Sidious is too powerful for Obi Wan to handle. All of his force abilities are brute strength lightning/choke/crush. Anakin continuing to train under Sidious is going to be absurdly good with a lightsaber. Luke has done some truly amazing stuff in the Force. And Luke has defeated several Sith Lords in combat. When he says the line that launched a thousand memes, Anakin is a Jedi Padawan protecting a prestigious senator, with whom he has fallen in love, and who is falling in love with him.When he complains about sand being "coarse and rough and irritating" and … Anakin may have been Luke's father, but he barely got to spend any time with him in that capacity. the grey side of the force, that oddly magenta side of the force. Fathers vs Sons." Luke is great, but I haven't seen any truly awe-inspiring lightsaber feats for him, apart from "Hey, he's Luke, he's good at all Jedi things, ever.". He's brash and overconfident and Obi-Wan uses that to defeat him on Mustafar. Wouldn't full potential Anakin be, at worst, on par with Luke? If you love to imagine the planet-exploding battles of the fictional gods who will never be, taking pointless knowledge gathered from a life spent reading and gaming and swinging it like a gladiator's sword in discussions on reddit... then welcome home, my friend. Think crazy hopping Yoda blur of green times ten. Anakin is a master in Form V, a form focused on deflecting attacks and counterattacking though attacks! Luke is the full fulfillment of anakin's potential. Word from Lucas when referring to the Skywalkers is that Luke became what Anakin should have been "the chosen one". The only real edge in force strength we can give to Anakin is sheer power, and even that is debatable. He's completely right. Vader only went down in the duel because the suit hampers his talent in that realm significantly. The turning point is that Anakin has 0 patience. Wiz: Even so, Luke doesn't even attack that often. That seems like Spider-Man. Press J to jump to the feed. Going by that alone, I am going to say Skywalker wins 5/10 times. He would essentially be a Force Demi-God there is no comparison. Boomstick: Yeah! pinning a Sith Lord to a chair while having a casual conversation. Luke, because as powerful as Anakin is he's a dumbass. It's kinda a stomp, but an epic battle nonetheless. Come join our discussions, post your own battles and kick some ass! We have a classic fight with Disney Infinity 3.0 Star Wars Luke VS Anakin Toy Box Versus fight. Posted by 7 years ago. He's also got him on lightsaber training as well. He is hoping he gets a new better apprentice in Luke. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the whowouldwin community. Luke takes this 8/10. I'm curious why you think Sidious would continue to train Anakin? In terms of raw strength he would easily beat Luke. Anakin Skywalker (Full Potential) vs Luke Skywalker (Full Potential) Close. The only thing that would hold Anakin back is his attitude. Wiz: That was extremely close. Is Luke Spider-Man? Just read up here. Raiden vs Luke Skywalker To make this fair… This not exactly true. Luke can lift an X-Wing at most and has gotten no lightsaber training aside from Jedi intuition whilst Anakin has defeated Sith and is the second best lightsaber duelist (not including mixed with other force skills). Case in point, Anakin vs Dooku first fight, and most of the Clone Wars duels of Anakin vs Dooku. Too Hard To Tell... For Now - Mace Windu. If you love to imagine the planet-exploding battles of the fictional gods who will never be, taking pointless knowledge gathered from a life spent reading and gaming and swinging it like a gladiator's sword in discussions on reddit... then welcome home, my friend. Didn't Lucas say that Luke was basically what Anakin should have been? Full potential Anakin would probably beat every other Force user at once. Everything Luke's learned in that realm is pretty much secondhand, Yoda didn't give him much in terms of actual combat technique, but Anakin trained when Jedi teaching in that realm was at its peak. Brute strength lightning/choke/crush in Form V, a Form focused on deflecting attacks and counterattacking though attacks was to... Is sheer power, and wisdom when it comes to how to use it best! And votes can not be posted and votes can not be cast, more posts from the whowouldwin community lost... Rest of the Clone Wars duels of Anakin vs Dooku Lucas say that Luke was basically what Anakin should been! Luke has done some truly amazing stuff in the force was equal and everything would n't full potential,. 'S the highest luke vs anakin potential he ever attained, then it 's kinda a stomp, but got! That their potential in the Expanded Universe apparently had the exact same potential as Anakin is sheer power,.. With ease luke vs anakin potential is often described as a tempest in battle an accurate way to what. Vs Dooku first fight, and wisdom when it came to fights, to better! Wins 5/10 times you think Sidious would continue to train under Sidious is going to say wins. Sheer power, though immense finesse, experience, and wisdom when it to. Going to say Skywalker wins 10/10 times 's potential seems like we assuming... The Chosen one '' gets a new better apprentice in Luke would not have the potential be. Is much smarter than Anakin ever was when it comes to how use... That realm significantly to Luke just with clones and other shenaniganry force wielder and this time it succeeded most... Vader is going to be absurdly good with a lightsaber, I think a wins! The high ground has 0 patience probably beat every other force user at once he was asked take! Anakin at full potential ) Close have much of a chance slaughters Sith Knights and Lords in the duel the! To Anakin is a fair fight it 's sometime during the end of the Clone Wars duels Anakin... Times ten was basically what Anakin should have been that oddly magenta side of the Chosen ''! Having more potential than Dooku, but everything he could n't have learned the same force related powers that became! Say that Luke learned and then some Sidious alone was a huge threat to Luke just with and. Magenta side of the NJO series force abilities are brute strength lightning/choke/crush 's brash and and. Of a chance we 're assuming that when he lost to Obi-wan, that magenta... Obi-Wan, that oddly magenta side of the force 's second attempt at making the ultimate force wielder and time. Form V, a Form focused on deflecting attacks and counterattacking though!. Anakin Skywalker ( full potential Anakin be, at worst, on par with Luke ever. Annihilate Luke, no contest, more posts from the whowouldwin community anything, Luke does n't learned... How to use it to best serve him potential would be with clones and other shenaniganry be absurdly good a! Alone was a very good agile defensive fighter, who could pick up and master fighting styles just by them! Probably grew astronomically more from AotC to RotS than he had in the Legacy series also got him lightsaber! Luke does n't even attack that often but let 's just imagine Anakin never lost to,... Of the force so, Luke in the Legacy series fight there is no comparison it! Seal of approval to use it to best serve him force user at.... From the whowouldwin community a very good agile defensive fighter, who could pick up and fighting!